• Fantasy map articles
  • How to draw maps
  • Map resources
  • Worldbuilding Framework

Worldbuilding School

An online resource for building imaginary worlds.

  • About
  • Library
  • Fantasy Map Market
    • How to Draw Mountains
    • Map Generator for Photoshop
  • Contact

How reddit helped improve a fantasy map

By Nate 'Vancano' Smith Leave a Comment

How reddit helped improve a fantasy map

This is the story all about how reddit helped improve my fantasy map.

I’ve long been told that reddit is a hostile place and the community can be fickle but that’s not true for r/worldbuilding. When I shared a fantasy map and asked for feedback and ideas the community was amazing.

I want to say a massive thank you to everyone who upvoted (well over 1,000 upvotes) or commented (over 110 comments) on the map.

In fact, so many people provided their thoughts, ideas and recommendations that it became hard to keep track of them all in reddit. So I’ve created this article to serve as a checklist to go through when making the next version of the map.

If your comment or recommendation isn’t on the list below then I’m still adding comments to the list (but it’s late so I’m heading to bed). Check back soon and hopefully it’ll be there.

The first version

This is the first map I published on r/worldbuilding. It was created in Photoshop using Vancano’s map generator. You can view the original reddit thread here.

Vancano fantasy world map

First thing I want to highlight are the pirates! A lot of people imagined pirates and big sea battles happening around this map. So I wanted to reassure the worldbuilding redditers that oh yes there will be pirates. And oh yes, there will be a whole lot of sea adventure and mischief.

Recommendations from the community

As I said earlier, the worldbuilding community was amazing and they provided LOADS of ideas and recommendations. I’m working through all of the comments and making them into a task list so I can then come back and make the suggested edits.

Vulturedoors
The top half kinda looks like a huge crater from an ancient asteroid impact. Like it hit and made ripples outward that formed land rings.

llortris
Suggested some of the civilizations might make polders to drain the sea and create more land for agriculture and living.

Operativehog
To answer your questions I wouldn’t change anything because this is perfectly good and workable. And I would start by looking at Japan elevation and river maps. You sorta have a narrow island similar to japan so that’s why I say that

LeStryker also supported the idea of Japan as an inspiration for the mountains and they recommended I look into the Sengoku era.

Chief_Broseph
you should have little to no islands in the forward direction and most to all islands on the trailing side of the plate.

Fezz1Doctor2
The Bottom half looks absolutely fantastic, but the top half seems to have to many big Islands. You should reduce the number of islands or make them smaller

Filed Under: Fantasy map

About Nate 'Vancano' Smith

Nathan is the founder of the Worldbuilding School. It's his goal to make worldbuilding easier for the 1000's of people who build their own world - whether it's for fun or profit. He's also works as a content strategist and can help you build an audience for your stories.

Like this article?

If you enjoyed this article and would like to support the Worldbuilding School then you can buy a map related product from the Fantasy Map Market, or you could buy me a coffee so I can push through the child induced sleepless nights and write more.

Write for us

Do you love worldbuilding? Would you like to write for the Worldbuilding School?

Register your interest and I’ll send you more info about how to write for us.

Advert

Do you need a world map for your novel or campaign?

Vancano’s Map Generator will help you create one.

Popular Posts

The Author’s Guide to Drawing Maps

22 Great Map Resources and Tutorials

The Worldbuilding Framework

How to generate random rettain using Photoshop

Adding tectonic plates to your world map

Articles on Brandon Sanderson

Worldbuilder’s Article Hunt #2

Author's Guide to Drawing Maps

Advert

About Nate Smith

Nate is the founder of the Worldbuilding School. It's his goal to make worldbuilding easier for the many people who build their own imaginary world - whether it's for fun or profit. As part of this goal he uses his skills in Cartography to draw maps. Read More…

Coming Soon!

This is where I hint at the projects, articles and reviews I’m working on:

  • New Resource Library – LIVE!
  • World Anvil Review
  • Dawn of Worlds Review – LIVE!
  • Triangle of Worldbuilding
  • Worldbuilding Monthly Newsletter

 

About

The WorldBuilding School is dedicated to helping authors, role players and games designers build their own imaginary world. Learn More.

Bring Your World To Life

Products

  • Write for us
  • Advertise with us
  • Affiliates
  • Worldbuilding Library
  • Vancano’s Map Generator
  • Author’s Guide to Drawing Maps

Resources

  • Worldbuilding tools
  • Worldbuilding guide
  • Worldbuilding resources
  • Worldbuilding Framework
  • 7 Key skills of a master worldbuilder
  • Fantasy map icons

Copyright © 2021 | Nate Smith | Privacy | Cookies | A Worldbuilding Colab project.

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. Accept Reject Read More
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled

Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.

Non-necessary

Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.

You’re 50% there!
50-complete

Receive Updates From The Experiment

All you need to do is enter your email address below: